marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

the options for the Adult Problem

Was contemplating the Adult Problem today:  in a novel with a young protagonist dealing with more than growing up -- say, alien invasion, tyrannical government, etc. -- the adults have to be kept out the limelight to allow the protagonist to solve the problem.  BUT --

This means the adults, I thought, had to be physically absent, evil, or incompetent incapable. (Most adults who can't take over for the kids are incompetent, but there are times when they are legitimately not capable of doing what the kids can do.)

But, it occurs to them that there's a fourth option, albeit it somewhat limited:  ignorance.  Which often overlaps.  An adult who dismisses a story from a child who has always been reliable in the past, or who has evidence, is evil or incompetent.  But the child may have no evidence, the story may be so wild that imagination would be indeed be more plausible, the child may have a long history as a liar. . . .

Magical or other enforcement of silence on the child is another option.  And the effect of physical absence can be introduced by having the adults being unable to keep the secret -- perhaps they are questioned under magical truth-telling, or perhaps the possibility is, however distance, a real enough problem that only children, deemed trivial, can act.  (In which case, physical absence is better for the child, who doesn't have to actively hide every dangerous clue.)

2But while the set-up requires finesse and other world-building conditions, ignorance is a complete excuse for inaction.
Tags: genre: ya, motives and purposes, plot devices

  • dealing with the witch

    ding-dong the witch is dead -- The first one at any rate. I comment on her body first, but then I elaborate on the breaking of her spells.…

  • weaving another thread

    Oh, my. This story bursts past in outlines in New and Unusual Ways. The entire -- long -- episode where she gets taken on a journey and shown a lot…

  • the adult problem in a scene

    Most of a work in progress solves the adult problem by having the narrator face age-appropriate problems. Only when she gets to be an adult does she…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded