marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

the DM vs the writer

Was pondering a GameLit world and how many characters would have levels. . . and questions of realism. . . .

If you define "realism" as "not making the reader notice the hand of the writer (however artfully done) in the limit," there's no way to do it except making them a dime a dozen, and that even if you make leveling much harder than it is in game. The idea that a party of adventurers can fight through six encounters in a day, and hit second level, but a shepherd can fight off wolves two or three times every winter for decades, or a caravan guard fight an encounter every month, again for decades, without leveling zeroth level -- well, you can fudge up reasons why the party can do it and the commoners can, but they are fudged up. (Their ability scores aren't that much better.)

I have read an argument that not all priests can be cleric-class because then 2.5% of the population would be clerics, and if all the classes claimed an equal representation (not an axiom I would put weight on, but grant it for argument), then 30% of the population would be leveled. To which I say, Henry VIII made it law that every man between the age of 15 to 60 years old should have a bow and arrows for it, and practice. If women can do the same in a D&D world, they would, or the kingdom would be overrun by the one where the women were thus trained. And in your typical D&D world, most of them would have a chance to use that.

And, of course, the classes would not be evenly distributed. Fighter would probably be commonest, but cleric would be close after.
Tags: role-playing games, the dm vs the writer, world-building: social structure

  • Mistress of the Waves

    Mistress of the Waves by George Phillies On another world, the narrator is fishing from her boat when an off-worlder is swept from his. She has to…

  • Pirate of the Prophecy

    Pirate of the Prophecy by Jack Campbell Empress of the Endless Sea book 1. A prequel series. I don't think there are any spoilers for Pillars of…

  • Boundless

    Boundless by Jack Campbell The Lost Fleet: Outlands book 1 -- the third series. Spoilers ahead for the first two. Opens with delivering evidence,…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded