marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

the disadvantage of hindsight

One more reason to read primary source. . . .

You can't really avoid hindsight if you know anything about a historical event.  This is just fine if you are writing about history, where you want to know what's really going on, but if you are ripping off history for fun and profit, it's a problem, because there, what you want is to know what the people thought of it at the time.

They didn't know that the heir to the throne would die in childbirth.  They didn't realize that the king would die young.  They had no way to know that a politician's abrupt change of rhetoric was purely strategic and did not indicate a change of mind in the slightest.  And realizing what it meant to think like that is the key to getting inside their heads, which is what is really needed to rip off the era for characterization tricks.

Reading between the lines is even more fun when figuring out what it is that the writers are taking absolutely for granted.
Tags: characterization, primary source, research

  • The Dragon Queen

    The Dragon Queen by Rod Espinosa The Courageous Princess book 3. Spoilers ahead for the first two. Because it opens with Mabelrose the prisoner of…

  • The Unremembered Lands

    The Unremembered Lands by Rod Espinosa The Courageous Princess book 2. Spoilers ahead for the earlier volume Mabelrose's father is trying to…

  • Beyond the Hundred Kingdoms

    Beyond the Hundred Kingdoms by Rod Espinosa The Courageous Princess book 1. The beloved Princess Mabelrose, her parents' only child, goes to a…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded