marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

J. R. R. Tolkien: Author of the Century

J. R. R. Tolkien:  Author of the Century by Tom Shippey

In which he takes another look at Tolkien's writings.  With surprisingly little overlap with The Road to Middle Earth.

The Edwardian middle-class nature of hobbits.  Why Tolkien invented the plural "dwarves."  The confusions of the Council at Rivendell, which could have moved along much more briskly if Elrond had acted like a proper chairman, but in its form, contained many levels of language.  The interlacing of the plot elements in The Lord of the Rings, handled much more competently than those in the medieval romances he took it from.  What sort of name Frodo is, and its real world legendary equivalent.

I think his analysis of evil is a little lacking here as in Road, where it does overlap.  He cites Boethius's statement that all fortune is good to describe the view that evil is a privation, except that fortune is what happens to you.  It does not entail their being no evil in how it happened to happen.  (Positive evil can arise in a world where all things are good, and evil is only privation; by choosing a lesser good over a greater one.)

It touches rather more on how the works are related to the modern world.  Like the situation at the end, in the Shire, which reflects a lot of societies where the government is running everything and bungling it all.
Tags: j. r. r. tolkien, lit crit, non-historical non-fiction reviews

  • The Arabian Nights

    The Arabian Nights translated by Husain Haddawy Based on one of the older and more unified Syrian manuscripts. It has only two hundred and…

  • Latin American Folktales

    Latin American Folktales by John Bierhorst A large variety. On top of tales, also riddles and prayers, and the tales come in all sorts of forms.…

  • Leaves from the Garden of Eden

    Leaves from the Garden of Eden: One Hundred Classic Jewish Tales by Howard Schwartz A collection of tales. A number from his earlier collections.…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded