marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

historical history

Fictional history can be hard enough, filling up the gaps.

Real life history can be a real bear.  Or perhaps, a strait jacket would a better analogy.

Hmm, or trellis?  (Writers can get silly on metaphors.)  The events of the story must grow about the fixed structure of historical events, which were not themselves in any genre.  William Wallace fighting King Edward ends with Wallace executed after a crushing Scottish defeat.  No matter how dashing Robin Hood is, Richard the Lion-Hearted will die and leave John on the throne.  (Assuming, of course, you use Richard and John in your story.)  Any romance between Louis XIV and any woman is doomed, even if you tie it off nicely in the story.

Some expurgation of events and reordering things can work, but does make the knowledgeable reader notice.

Some writers get it so ineptly that it's more clumsy than fictional history.  Most manage well enough, but there can be points where you see the strain.  Some pull it off elegantly.  I once read a work where the hero stalked King John to kill him.  Impossible, of course.  But King John's actual death, collapsing when his treasure was lost when the tide came in, and dying the next day, worked wonderfully well to curb the hero's arrogant certainty.  But beside the elegant working in of his change with the events -- and the careful character development -- it needed the right events.  History is seldom so obliging.
Tags: fictional history, story structure

  • Julia's House Moves On

    Julia's House Moves On by Ben Hatke The second Julia picture book. Julia decides that they need to move the house. Everyone's unhappy. So she…

  • Witch Hat Atelier, Vol. 6

    Witch Hat Atelier, Vol. 6 by Kamome Shirahama Spoilers ahead for the first five volume. As in, they arrive at the magical city (underwater!) with…

  • Aru Shah and the Tree of Wishes

    Aru Shah and the Tree of Wishes by Roshani Chokshi Pandava Quartet book 3. Spoilers ahead for the earlier work The tale continues -- taking up…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded