marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

Critiquing Someone Else's Work

A discussion of what to do and how to do it.

there's beta readers and groups that meet and groups online.  There are, more importantly, groups that are too soft and inoffensive, vs. groups that take pride in eviscerating the victims, which call for a good moderator.  Of course, then there's the question of getting one.  One model is that everyone gets a turn to speak about a story, the writer last, and then you get a free-for-all.

If all the readers think there's a problem with something, there's a problem.  Of course, they may be entirely wrong about what the problem is.

The delicate art of filtering one's criticism, because either changing to meet all expectations or rejecting it all is pointless.  (It's also impossible to meet them all, because they can contradict each other.)

Focus on the big picture -- plot, characters, etc.  The little phrasing problems  will be swept away in the fixing of those, if replaced by new ones.  (I didn't get a chance to observe that if it's a systemic problem, like wordiness or dangling participles, that can help.  But certainly sentence-level problems aren't so big as the higher-level ones.)

Putting stuff aside before revising and then submitting it to readers.

One question was about how to cope with rage, despair, and only then getting down to tackling the crits.  Answers were:  you're doing fine as long as you do tackle them; make sure you don't abuse the readers, and take notes.
Tags: arisia, revision

  • dealing with the witch

    ding-dong the witch is dead -- The first one at any rate. I comment on her body first, but then I elaborate on the breaking of her spells.…

  • observations about inspiration

    One can discuss what the effect of power levels, and number of superheroes, are on world-building. But when building a superhero story, one doesn't…

  • Appendix N

    Appendix N: The Eldritch Roots of Dungeons and Dragons by Peter Bebergal A selection of works from the famous D&D Appendix N. With some…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded