marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

philosophical speculation about rewriting

I've read Treasure Island.  I've also watched Treasure Planet, which has its charms, and definitely went to re-write Island on Disney's terms.

Not always perfectly.  But it's odd to notice that they had to make the crew all pirates in the movie.  You'd think that increasing the number of villains would make it worse, but this way they could finesse the problem of disposing of the honest hands, who could not be corrupted,  In the book, of course, Jim gets to witness the treacherous murder of one -- triggered by hearing the death scream of another honest sailor.

Though the movie did have an alien captain, who might actually, unlike a human one, love gold for gold's sake.

When breaking a story loose from its frame to change something like that, it can be very hard to avoid being trapped by the old story

Tags: plotting

  • Starship's Mage

    Starship's Mage by Glynn Stewart This is the first volume of a series but works on its own. It's also a compilation of independent episodes, which…

  • Middle-Earth: Journeys in Myth and Legend

    Middle-Earth: Journeys in Myth and Legend by Donato Giancola Artwork based on Tolkien's tales. Many gorgeous oil paintings, and a lot of good…

  • Beyond the Clouds

    Beyond the Clouds, Vol. 1 by Nicke The opening of a definite series. Our hero, the youngest apprentice, is sent to do maintenance on the town…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded