marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

the gods and belief

A lot of writers, constructing their religions, make the gods absolutely dependent on human belief.  Some invoke the obvious reason:  the gods were made by belief. 

And I hate, hate, hate it.

I think the worst case was Harry Turtledove's Case of the Toxic Spelldump, where the main character purports to be a Jew.  Goes to the synagogue, even.  He's an idolater.  He explicitly thinks that his belief (lumped in with others) creates that which he worships.  Silly, silly, silly.

But it's seldom better in explicitly polytheistic systems.  It seldom allows the Powers That Be to be noticeably numinous.  And, oddly enough, it tends toward the gods acting like three-year-olds.  Despite the obvious problem of -- if the humans made them like this, why oh why are the humans any better?

Tags: rants, world-building: deities, world-building: metaphysics, world-building: non-human characters, world-building: religion

  • rewriting legends

    Was pondering Robin Hood and legends in general after re-reading Howard Pyle's Merry Adventures of Robin Hood. It did not hold up to childhood…

  • dithering and openings

    Am I dithering too much in the opening? Mind you, I have her face a problem on the first page and get stuck with some work (which I immediately…

  • supplies

    It may be wise to have the hero and heroine buy food, they know they are in danger of being unable to buy, owing to magic. But either I have to use…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded