marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,
marycatelli
marycatelli

Harry Potter and fairy tales

Talk about implausible -- Muggle fairy tales and wizard ones are not similar.

Even if the wizards had hermetically sealed themselves off, this is very implausible.  Such glimpses of fairy tales as we get from pre-modern times are recognizably fairy tales, however they have been altered by rewriting to other genres. Not to mention that, while the great wizardly withdrawal was prior to the Brothers Grimm, the fairy tale dispersal shows the recognizably same tale all over the place. If they spread, they did before the seal-off, and if they spontaneously originate in all sorts of places, they would do it among wizards too, who aren't that different.

(No, magic doesn't make that much difference. There are certainly fairy tales that do not feature magic at all, so finding it a reality would not mean rejecting tales for that reason.)

Not to mention the Muggleborn. Certainly young halfbloods would be regaled at the family fire with the tales their parent grew up with.
Tags: fairy tales in stories, families: parent/child, harry potter, world-building: magic (effects)
Subscribe

  • tale of a child

    There are fairy tales with child protagonists, of course. If you read up on them, there are even tales that start with child protagonists who are…

  • dealing with the witch

    ding-dong the witch is dead -- The first one at any rate. I comment on her body first, but then I elaborate on the breaking of her spells.…

  • ages of history

    So, once upon a time, there were evil wizards making everyone miserable. Some of the more minor wizards banded together and took over and made…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments