marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,
marycatelli
marycatelli

plot hole

Was pondering things about Harry Potter and noticed one particularly glaring one.

Albus Dumbledore.  Sirius Black.  Peter Pettigrew.

Notice two names conspiciously missing from that list of people considered as candiates for the Potters' Secret Keeper.

James Potter and Lily Potter.

Why couldn't James have just been his own Secret Keeper the way Bill was for himself and Fleur?  Or Arthur Weasley for Aunt Muriel's, when they hid there?

Besides, of course, the way that the entire series would have collapsed like a house of cards without that.

The irony is that it could have been fixed with one simple switch:  Bill and Arthur could have changed duties, so Bill was Secret Keeper for Aunt Muriel's, and Arthur for the Shell Cottage.  Since Dumbledore did not live at Sirius Black's, that would have made an invariable rule that a location can only be protected by a Secret Keeper who is not resident there.
Tags: harry potter, plot devices, world-building: buildings, world-building: magic (plot device)
Subscribe

  • for the birds

    Wading through the story, throwing in birds here and there. Enough to ensure that the reader knows that there are always birds, often of strange and…

  • outlines and subplots

    I think there are going to be subplots. I know that one villainess likes intrigue, and another likes handing magical tutoring to foolish young folk…

  • so that's the problem

    figuring out the weakness of the opening: it's two scenes, and the first is mostly info-dumping. It should start in the forest, talking about…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 6 comments