marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,
marycatelli
marycatelli

pondering the ways of muses

read some fannish speculation about Harry Potter a bit back, about the Dursleys.

This fannish theory was that the reason the Dursleys spoiled Dudley was that they were deathly afraid that he would be as stricken by the news that Harry was a wizard as Petunia had been, by Lily, so they were trying to beef up his confidence before then.  (Humanizing them far past their comic role in the actual books.)

For some reason, I remembered that theory today.  And poked at it a bit.  And realized that the really, truely, honestly most horrible thing that could happen then -- or even without this theory -- would be if Harry turned out to be a wizard -- and so did Dudley.

Just imagine the scene where their boy observes that one of the letters was addressed to him.

Though actually, it wouldn't work.  Dudley is too limited to type to work as a character for the bulk of a book.  But with the serial numbers filed off and the Dudley equivalent getting some actual character, that would be an interesting plot twist.  One wonders if the Dursleys equivalent in such a story would not just turn both children out of doors and never deal with them again.
Tags: characterization, families: other, families: parent/child, filing off serial numbers, harry potter, inspiration, motive (source)
Subscribe

  • When Earth's last picture is painted

    When Earth's last picture is painted And the tubes are twisted and dried When the oldest colors have faded And the youngest critic has died We shall…

  • from spiraling ecstatically

    from spiraling ecstatically this proud nowhere of earth's most prodigious night blossoms a newborn babe: around him, eyes –gifted with every…

  • from spiraling ecstatically

    from spiraling ecstatically this proud nowhere of earth's most prodigious night blossoms a newborn babe: around him, eyes –gifted with every…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments