marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

fairy tales within tales

there's a large difference between a character recounting a fairy tale within a story -- and a character recounting some backstory that happens to be a fairy tale because they live in a fairy tale world.

The first one gets chosen for metaphorical and thematic significance.  Even from the character's point of view, though he may delude himself about motives.  If it happens to alert the characters about correct actions later, there's a touch of irony about it, and probably it needs to be either given a twist, or have character comment on how this isn't a fairy tale.

The second one is just history.  A character might comment on the coincidence of having to go hunt for his wife over sea and land like in the tale, but it's the sort of thing that happens.

Not that it can't be retold by a character for reasons of metaphorical and thematic significance. . . says the writer, having just written a scene in which a son and mother discuss the reasons why she can't rescue her husband, should he fall captive, the way her grandmother rescued her grandfather -- and the son thinks but does not say that, in addition, his mother doesn't love his father enough to do that.
Tags: backstory, fairy tales in stories, families: matrimony, families: parent/child, fictional history, metaphor, motives and purposes, plot twist, point of view, theme

  • The World Between Blinks

    The World Between Blinks by Amie Kaufman and Ryan Graudin Cousins Marisol and Jake are at the packing up of their grandmother's house before the…

  • The Fate of Earth

    The Fate of Earth by Jeramey Kraatz Space Runners book 4. Spoilers ahead for the first three, because this really isn't stand alone Our fearless…

  • The Arabian Nights

    The Arabian Nights translated by Husain Haddawy Based on one of the older and more unified Syrian manuscripts. It has only two hundred and…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded