marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

epic and tales

Have been philosophically contemplating epics and fantasy and the TriWizard Tournament. . .

One problem with epic fantasy (or SF) is that, unlike an epic tale of historical fiction, you can't do against the backdrop of a known epic event. An epic tale of WWII would probably concentrate on as few characters as the main ones of The Lord of the Rings, but taking the background more of less as read.

Harry Potter has perhaps more of a disadvantage, because it's a bildungsroman as well. Keeping it all in Harry's view kept a lot of things off-stage. Take the Tournament, which is, on the face of it, not consistent with Dumbledore's character, even as fully revealed in the end. To foment unity in the wizarding community, he would have come up with something less lethal and less focused. A longer work might have scenes where he was forced to take it as a price of getting anything, or even continuing in his position. He would have put a good face on it for the students, so it would all be invisible to them.

Of course, it might have turned into an interminable series, then.
Tags: bildungsroman, genre: fantasy, genre: historical fiction, harry potter, story length

  • When Earth's last picture is painted

    When Earth's last picture is painted And the tubes are twisted and dried When the oldest colors have faded And the youngest critic has died We shall…

  • Middle-Earth: Journeys in Myth and Legend

    Middle-Earth: Journeys in Myth and Legend by Donato Giancola Artwork based on Tolkien's tales. Many gorgeous oil paintings, and a lot of good…

  • from spiraling ecstatically

    from spiraling ecstatically this proud nowhere of earth's most prodigious night blossoms a newborn babe: around him, eyes –gifted with every…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded