marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

The Man Behind The Iron Mask

The Man Behind The Iron Mask by John Noone

A review of the legends and the realities.

Yes, there was a prisoner kept masked -- velvet, it seems, not iron. But things expanded from there. From Voltaire's hints, where he points out with great portentousness but, unfortunately no accuracy, that no one prominent vanished the year the man was arrested, that lead to the most common story, the twin of Louis XIV -- not, as it turns out, plausible, because all accounts agreed that the man in the mask was tall, and Louis XIV was, in fact, rather short. There is even a story that the man married the governor's daughter, and the Bonapartes were descended from the union.

Some of the others include an Italian involved in certain intrigues (the mask is credited to an Italian custom of wearing them to protect the face from teh sun), a princess (Louis XIV was substituted for her so Louis XIII would have an heir -- this theory comes from supporters of his brother Philippe's descendants, who would then be the rightful heir), an illegitimate son of Anne of Austria, an illegitimate son of Louis XIV, an illegitimate son of Charles II, the man that a secret society wanted to make king (kept alive so they would not go to a new candidate), and more.

His own theory was the prisoner was as obscure as he seemed from other evidence, and the drama was done by the prison governor to make his position look important.

It really is hard to reconcile the obsessive care taken with the prisoner with the menial treatment he also got.

Also touches on a lot of related topics, like prison and the justice system. Useful for anyone who wants to steal a melodramatic plot.
Tags: history reviews: 15th-18th centuries

  • Hardtack and Coffee

    Hardtack and Coffee or, The Unwritten Story of Army Life by John Davis Billings The go-to book if you want the details of army life in the…

  • down the rabbit hole half way

    Because I want to look at the dirt. You look up the composition of dirt and you can get how much of it is inorganic, and some of what elements may…

  • serendipity and decision

    So the writer is working on a world with plentiful bird-maidens (swan, dove, peahen, etc.) who can turn from woman to bird and back as long as they…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded