marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

Non-Feudal Political Systems in Fantasy

I was on this one.  And derailed it in the first minutes by commenting that actually, most fantasy, though pseudo-medieval, are not in fact, very feudal in structure.

So we panelists hashed out how badly they do it, with the lack of the structures of vassals and all that.  And one panelist objected that it was a response to a very specific set of circumstances and another said that it has, actually, arisen in other situations.

About half way through it lurched on to the topic of governmental systems that are atypical of fantasy.  I mentioned the Shire, which is a Kropotkin-type anarchy and populated by hobbits, who are much better than humans and complacent unimaginative stick-in-the-muds, which is why it works.

The Empire and a panelist complained about how simple Empires are, with the Emperor, who has free time, and a few officials.  Especially Galactic Empires.  (I recommended the Ciaphas Cain and Gaunt's Ghosts series to him afterward, and he observed that games often do it better because the gamers expected it.  True, and the better Warhammer 40000 tie-in use it!)

The description asked if Marxism could work in a fantasy world, I said it didn't work in the real world, and another panelist said it could only work in a fantasy world, and thus we exhausted that in two sentences.

Update: 'cause I remembered something important -- we also riffed on how much you should go into.  Absolute monarchs without vast bureaucracies mean you just have to convince the king, rather than all the log rolling you would have to do in, say, the US.  If the politics is not central to the story, that may be just what the writer needs to keep the focus where it belongs for that story -- off the politics.
Tags: arisia, politics, world-building: government, world-building: nobility, world-building: royalty, world-building: social bonds, world-building: social structure

  • Ghost in the Vision

    Ghost in the Vision by Jonathan Moeller Ghost Night book 7, spoilers ahead for the earlier books -- and earlier series. Caina arrives Istarinmul,…

  • Appendix N

    Appendix N: The Eldritch Roots of Dungeons and Dragons by Peter Bebergal A selection of works from the famous D&D Appendix N. With some…

  • Witch Hat Atelier #7

    Witch Hat Atelier #7 by Kamome Shirahama Spoilers ahead for the first six. Does resolve whether Coco leaves Qifery for another master, and talk…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded