marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,

chaotic evil vs. lawful evil

Not the D&D alignments, which are as messy and incoherent as the rest of the alignment system.

But -- is the evil in the world organized and unified, or not?

Chaotic evil has the disadvantage of not being able to attain levels of scale that lawful evil can, and it being much easier for the good guys to pit one evil against other, but then again, it doesn't have to work with the inherent problems of unified evil requiring internal good (the evil beings of an organization must be able to trust each other, be loyal, work together, tell each other the truth, at least a degree), and if its neighbor evil is destroyed, it can go on, untroubled. Which makes plotting more difficult, since you don't want it to get episodic.

Not there's an abyss between them. The Lord of the Rings put forward a lot of pure chaotic evil -- on top of the infighting that is an inherent problem with lawful evil -- such as Old Man Willow and Caradhras.

But the big difference between them is thematic. Chaotic evil means there's always another evil lurking around the corner when you've finished off this one. (Useful for series, no doubt.) And so the endings are more ambiguous.
Tags: always evil, conflict, endings, orchestrating characters, theme, world-building: social bonds, world-building: social structure

  • The Dragon Queen

    The Dragon Queen by Rod Espinosa The Courageous Princess book 3. Spoilers ahead for the first two. Because it opens with Mabelrose the prisoner of…

  • The Unremembered Lands

    The Unremembered Lands by Rod Espinosa The Courageous Princess book 2. Spoilers ahead for the earlier volume Mabelrose's father is trying to…

  • Beyond the Hundred Kingdoms

    Beyond the Hundred Kingdoms by Rod Espinosa The Courageous Princess book 1. The beloved Princess Mabelrose, her parents' only child, goes to a…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded