marycatelli (marycatelli) wrote,
marycatelli
marycatelli

weight and length

One thing may determine the suitable length of a story is not just how sticky the story ideas are, but the weight they can bear.

Doesn't matter for all ideas.  If you have a bright idea for a comic little interlude, it can fit as a piece of comic relief in a much longer work.  The trouble arises when you have a structural idea, that determines much of the story.

Particularly with climax.  A funny little climax, or a twist, can work with a short story, because it only has to bear the weight of the short story.  To stick it on a novel, with all the complexity of that a novel needs, would be to make it anticlimactic.  This is why a Feghoot is not only always a short story, but always a short-short; you can't have an entire novel leading up to a bad pun.

I wrestled with some ideas before I got the notion to put them little short-shorts, told in the character's voice.  The endings weren't strong enough to carry a longer story.

Sometimes this is the problem with padded novels.  It's not just that the padding wasn't integrated with the story.  It's the story really couldn't support a novel of this length, no matter how you integrated the stuff.
Tags: dramatic tension, endings, plotting, story length, story structure
Subscribe

  • encounters

    It's all very well to plan out how the heroine and the others escape from the evil and violent monsters. You still have to get them to meet in the…

  • center of the story

    All stories need outlines because otherwise they peter out in the middle. (sometimes they peter out in the outline, which is less frustrating.) They…

  • revising fast

    It helps to revise as quickly as you can, getting through the pages at speed. It means you are less likely to forgot, at page 203, what you wrote on…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 2 comments